Antioch Pizza Shop - Paddock Lake, WI

When it comes to pizza in Paddock Lake, Antioch Pizza Shop has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Nestled at 24730 75th St, this charming pizzeria offers a cozy atmosphere and a reputation for delicious food. Reviewers rave about the hot and ready pizza slices that come out fresh and flavorful every time. Samita Slack, a delighted customer, highlighted the amazing honey BBQ chicken and praised their enticing ice cream treats, like the M&M with Oreo flavor that had her hooked.

With a menu that includes unique items such as cheeseburger double dough pizza and barbecue chicken, there’s something for everyone. Customers like Ethan Z appreciate the quality, although he recommends opting for pickup due to longer delivery times. The attentive staff consistently receive high marks, ensuring orders are correct and meals are served with a smile, echoing Ann Moroe's sentiments about their friendly service.

GEO FISHING notes that Antioch's pizza is a cut above the corporate chains, offering a clean, delicious taste that locals prefer. Even though some find milkshakes slightly pricey, the fresh ingredients make them worth it, as Heather Pisano can attest. Overall, Antioch Pizza Shop is a must-visit for pizza lovers who crave fresh, hearty, and satisfying meals in a welcoming environment.